Page MenuHomeMiraheze

Extension review: FlowThread
Open, NormalPublic

Event Timeline

Zppix triaged this task as Normal priority.Oct 10 2019, 14:49
Zppix created this task.
Southparkfan added a subscriber: Southparkfan.

Don't we already have many security reviewed extensions providing these features?

@Aunst Per Southparkfan, have you tried other similar extensions and found that they were not suitable for you?

@Aunst Per Southparkfan, have you tried other similar extensions and found that they were not suitable for you?

Yes, I've tried Extension:Comments, but I think it isn't suitable for my wiki.

AmandaCath added subscribers: LiXia, Reception123.
AmandaCath added a subscriber: AmandaCath.

This has now been requested for a second wiki, esu.miraheze.org

In T4789#115677, @Aunst wrote:

@Aunst Per Southparkfan, have you tried other similar extensions and found that they were not suitable for you?

Yes, I've tried Extension:Comments, but I think it isn't suitable for my wiki.

Okay, for what reasons? Have you also tried Flow?

In T4789#115677, @Aunst wrote:

@Aunst Per Southparkfan, have you tried other similar extensions and found that they were not suitable for you?

Yes, I've tried Extension:Comments, but I think it isn't suitable for my wiki.

Okay, for what reasons? Have you also tried Flow?

@Reception123 Sorry for the wait. Because the Comments extension needs add parser hook tag to each of articles, I think it is inconvenient.

My wiki using Flow extension. But I think that extension is a talking system which replaces MediaWiki's native talk page, not a comment system.

I also tried CommentStreams extension, but it has some problems and not compatible with MobileFrontend extension.

Is this extension still wanted or will the existing comments extensions be sufficient. If it's still wanted I can try and get this task finally approved (or declined)

Is this extension still wanted or will the existing comments extensions be sufficient. If it's still wanted I can try and get this task finally approved (or declined)

Yes, I still want to use this extension.