Page MenuHomeMiraheze

Special:ManageWiki/permissions not synced with Special:ListGroupRights enough
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

On Special:ManageWiki/permissions user removes all permissions for
groups "user" and "*".

Now he checks Special:ListGroupRights but discovers for "user":

  • Edit pages protected as "Allow only logged in users" (user)
  • Manage OAuth grants (mwoauthmanagemygrants)

are still listed.

Event Timeline

Jidanni triaged this task as Normal priority.Nov 13 2019, 16:38
Jidanni created this task.
dross claimed this task.
dross subscribed.

These rights are not allowed to be unset by bureaucrats per Miraheze.

This is largely due to the requirements imposed by having global accounts. Certain features would break or be locked out if certain rights were not permanent, specifically those in the * and user group you have discovered.

OK, but they should then be shown as greyed out on Special:ManageWiki/permissions .

Also no control over

  • Edit pages protected as "Allow only logged in users" (user)

makes one worry that there is no way to turn off editing.
(But in fact it doesn't take priority over other permissions, so the worry is not real.)